Sustainable Development in Cities: A Qualitative Approach to Evaluate Rating Systems

Soheil Arabi, Mahmood Golabchi, Mehrab Darabpour


Sustainable development paradigm is one of the dominant paradigms of the century. In 1987, “Our Common Future,” the Brundtland Commission adopted the concept of “sustainable development” to challenge the dominant paradigm of development as equivalent to economic growth. Using rating systems is like a plan in order to implement sustainable development. Moreover, Tehran as the capital of Iran and a megalopolis needs an appropriate rating system to be assessed in context of sustainable development. Be that as it may, Selection of a rating system pivots on the paradigm of the planner that how the planner describes the development and what are the planner's preferences; and also on the priorities of the city planned to be developed. This research has tried to evaluate rating systems to unveil their qualities to afford city planners an opportunity to use an appropriate approach of sustainable development. Authors of this research hold the opinion that if planners' preferences and priorities of a city can be in step with a rating system, the best result will occur. Furthermore, it was decided to do the evaluation in the context of ASTM E2432. In this research rating systems of ISCA, BREEAM, LEED-ND, CASBEE, Green star, DGNB were chosen to be evaluated. On the other hand, the obstacles of implementing sustainable development in Tehran were identified. Finally, LEED-ND was identified as the best rating system among above-mentioned ones. Since the research was exploratory research, a qualitative approach was selected to do the evaluation. Consequently, structured interviewing was applied as a fitting method and the technique of pile sorting was used to collect data in interviews as well.


Sustainable Development in City; Rating System; Structured Interview; Pile Sorting Technique; Obstacles of Sustainable Development in Tehran.


Wang, R.S., Li, F., Hu, D., Li, B.L. "Understanding eco-complexity: Social-Economic-Natural Complex Ecosystem approach." Ecol. Complex 8(1) (2011): 15-29. doi:10.1016/j.ecocom.2010.11.001.

Riley, J. "Indicator quality for assessment of impact of multidisciplinary systems." Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 87(2) (November 2001): 121–128. doi:10.1016/S0167-8809(01)00272-9.

Riley, J. "The indicator explosion: local needs and international challenges." Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 87(2) (November 2001): 119-120. doi:10.1016/S0167-8809(01)00271-7.

Spangenberg, J.H.; Pfahl, S.; Deller, K. "Towards indicators for institutional sustainability: lessons from an analysis of Agenda 21." Ecological Indicators 2(1–2) (November 2002): 61-77 doi:10.1016/S1470-160X(02)00050-X.

Li, H.; Zhang, X.; Thomas, S.; Skitmore, M. "Quantifying Stakeholder Influence in Decision/Evaluations relating to Sustainable Construction in China – A Delphi Approach." Journal of cleaner production, (2017) doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.04.151.

Aligholizadeh Aghdam, K; Foroughi Rad, R; Shakeri, H and Majrouhi, J. " Approaching Green Buildings Using Eco-Efficient Construction Materials: A Review of the state-of-the-art." KICEM Journal of Construction Engineering and Project Management, 8(3) (Sep 2018) doi:10.6106/JCEPM.2018.8.3.001.

ASTM E2432-17. "Standard Guide for General Principles of Sustainability Relative to Buildings." ASTM International (2017) doi:10.1520/E2432-17.

ISO 15392 "Sustainability in building construction — General principles." (2008).

IEA (International Energy Agency). "Energy Technology Perspectives." (2017) ISBN PRINT 978-92-64-27050-3.

IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change). "Climate Change 2007 – Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability." Fourth Assessment Report of the IPCC (2007) ISBN: 978 0521 88010-7 Hardback; 978 0521 70597-4 Paperback.

Price, L.; De la Rue du Can, S.; Sinton, J., Worrell, E. "Sectoral Trends in Global Energy Use and GHG Emissions." Energy Policy 36(4) (April 2008): 1386-1403 doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2007.12.017.

Harvey, L.D.D. "A Handbook on Low-Energy Buildings and District Energy Systems: Fundamentals, Techniques, and Examples." (2006) ISBN: 978-1138965508.

AGIC. "Australian Green Infrastructure Council – IS Rating Scheme." Australian Green Infrastructure Council (AGIC), (January 7, 2013)

Keivani, R. "A review of the main challenges to urban sustainability." Int. J. Urban Sustainable Dev. 1(1–2) (2010): 5–16. doi:10.1080/19463131003704213.

Fernández-Sánchez, G., Rodríguez-López, F. "A methodology to identify sustainability indicators in construction project management—Application to infrastructure projects in Spain." Ecological Indicators J. 10(6) (November 2010): 1193-1201. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2010.04.009.

Zhang, L.L., Wang, L., Tian, J.X. "Study on sustainable construction management based on LCA." International Conference on Construction on Real Estate Management (2008).

ISO 21929-1 "Sustainability in building construction —Sustainability indicators, Part 1: Framework for the development of indicators and a core set of indicators for buildings." (2011).

Chethana S.; Vivian W.; Khoa, N. "Environmental, Economic, and Social Parameters in International Green Building Rating Tools." Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice, 143(2) (April 2017) doi:10.1061/(ASCE)EI.1943-5541.0000313

Gunn, L., Nicky D., Jacquelien, S. "Power supply–demand balance in a Smart Grid: An information sharing model for a market mechanism." Applied Mathematical Modelling, 38(13) (2014): 3350-3360. Doi:10.1016/j.apm.2013.11.042.

Smiciklas, J. "Connecting cities and communities with the Sustainable Development Goals." (2017) ISSN: 978-92-61-25371-4 (Electronic version).

BREEAM "BREEAM Communities technical manual." technical manual: version: SD202 (August 2017)

LEED "LEED for Cities Pilot | Performance Score to LEED Certification." (September 2017)

LEED ND. "LEED 2009 for Neighborhood Development Rating System. Congress for the New Urbanism." Natural Resources, Defense Council, and the U.S. Green Building Council (2014).

LEED. "Checklist: LEED v2009 Neighborhood Development." (September 2017)

CASBEE. "CASBEE for cities." (2014)

Anthony, M.; Jian, Z.; Yutao, W.; Jiayuan, W. "Readiness for sustainable community: A case study of Green Star Communities." Journal of Cleaner Production 173 (2017): doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.03.190.

DGNB. "The DGNB sustainability concept. The new quality of building. The German Sustainable Building Council (DGNB)." (2017)

ISCA. "IS Rating Scheme Categories and Credits." Infrastructure sustainability council of Australia (2007).

Morse, J. "Completing a qualitative project." Sage Publications (1997) ISBN: 9780761906018.

Whittemore R., Chase SK., Mandle CL. "Validity in qualitative research." Qual. Health Res. 11(4) (2001): 522–37. doi:10.1177/104973201129119299.

Weller, S. C.; Romney, A. K. "Qualitative Research Methods: Systematic data collection." SAGE Publications Ltd. (1988) doi: 10.4135/9781412986069.

Full Text: PDF

DOI: 10.28991/cej-03091215


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2018 Soheil Arabi, Mahmood Golabchi, Mehrab Darabpour

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.